Wenn es knirscht: Warum in Spannungen die Energie für Wachstum steckt

Healthy Tension in Leadership Teams: Where the Energy for Growth Comes From

Part 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes to read

In short

Tension in a leadership team is a signal, not a malfunction: when people push back, it means something matters to them. Our brains still prefer to avoid that kind of uncertainty, because it costs energy. Teams that put disagreements on the table early, and with curiosity, often find the answer none of them would have reached alone. Conflict is brilliant, if you know how to work with it.

I like it when a leadership team pushes back on each other. That may sound odd from someone who has worked with founder and leadership teams for more than 25 years. But when people disagree, it tells me one thing: someone here cares. In this article I explain why our brains would still rather walk around a disagreement, and why I so often say that conflict is brilliant.


How much does it cost you to make the same decision three times? Find out in one minute.


The team where nobody ever disagrees

When a leadership team tells me "we don't really have any conflict here", I start paying close attention. It rarely means everyone agrees. It usually means some things never make it onto the table.

People nod in the meeting and carry on the discussion in the corridor afterwards. The difficult decision travels politely from one agenda to the next. From the outside it looks like harmony. I call it graveyard calm with a coffee machine.

Yet it is completely normal for things to grind a little when people with different roles, values and ideas build a company together. I would even say it is a good sign. Especially in founding teams, where everyone brings a lot of heart and their own picture of what the company should become.

Why our brains don't love conflict

Our brains are big fans of stability. The reason is fairly unromantic: energy.

A frugal organ with a big appetite

The brain makes up only about 2% of our body weight, but at rest it uses around 20% of our energy (Raichle and Gusnard, 2002). No wonder it likes to save. It constantly predicts what will happen next, and as long as the prediction holds, it stays in power-saving mode.

A disagreement throws that prediction out. Suddenly nobody knows how this will go. And uncertainty switches on our stress system (Peters, McEwen and Friston, 2017). It feels uncomfortable, so we want to get rid of it as quickly as possible.

Let's just leave things as they are

On top of that comes an effect I know well from myself: we stick with what exists, even when another option would actually be better. Researchers call it status quo bias (Samuelson and Zeckhauser, 1988). In a leadership team it usually sounds like this: "Let's look at that again next week."

I find this view a real relief. Avoiding conflict is not a character flaw. It is a perfectly normal brain at work, and you can negotiate with a normal brain.

Where the energy in different perspectives lies

When two people in a leadership team disagree, I mainly see one thing: both of them care about something. One wants speed, the other wants quality. One is thinking about the next funding round, the other about the team that has to carry it. Both make sense.

That tension is often where the answer lies that neither would have found alone. That's why I say conflict is brilliant. Not because arguing is fun, but because there is so much energy in it that a team can move a great deal with it.

Something else I have learned over the years: a conflict doesn't disappear just because you keep it out of the meeting room. It simply moves, into side conversations, back channels and decisions that get reopened two weeks later.

Curiosity helps more than defence

What helps me most when things start to grind: getting curious. What is actually happening here? What is this really about?

Often the cause is surprisingly mundane. An unclear agreement, an open responsibility, or a word that everyone understands differently. My favourite example is "asap". For one person it means within the hour, for another sometime this week. And suddenly someone feels ignored, although nobody did anything wrong.

If you look at it early, it is usually sorted in five minutes. If you don't, it keeps simmering and grows.

And one more misunderstanding I hear a lot: respect doesn't mean everyone always agrees. I see the opposite. Teams where people like and respect each other are especially good at disagreeing, because nobody has to fear that pushing back will damage the relationship.

What I like to pass on to founders and leadership teams

If I had to put it into one thought: a conflict is a signal, not a malfunction. When things grind, something matters to someone. And the earlier a team talks about it, the easier it gets.

I like to compare it to a muscle. Every time you go through a disagreement together as a team and take a moment afterwards to see what you learned, it gets a little stronger. Not a fitness programme, more like taking the stairs every day.

If you read German and want to go deeper into why conflict in teams is not a bad thing, you'll find more here: Conflict in teams: why it is not negative (in German).

Part 2 looks at how you can tell when a disagreement tips over and stops helping, and starts draining energy instead.

Mehr dazu in Teil 2: Woran ihr merkt, dass es knirscht

Frequently asked questions

Is it normal for a leadership team to disagree a lot?

Yes, very. Wherever people with different roles and expectations decide together, tension builds. What interests me is less whether it grinds and more what a team does with it.

How can I tell whether a conflict moves us forward or holds us back?

My rule of thumb: if you come out of a discussion clearer than before and the decision holds, it was worth it. If the same discussion is on the agenda for the third time, probably not. More on this in Part 2 of this series.

Why do so many leaders avoid conflict?

Because uncertainty is hard work for our brains, and we like to stick with what we know. Avoiding it feels better in the moment. Over time it costs speed and good ideas. I know that from myself too.

What do you mean by "conflict is brilliant"?

I don't mean that arguing is fun. A conflict is a signal, not a malfunction: when two people in a leadership team disagree, both of them care about something. That tension often holds the answer neither would have found alone.


What about your team? Where do you see different perspectives right now that might hold exactly the energy you need for your next step?

If you'd like to look at it together: Book an intro call

Honest conversations. Clear decisions. One team.

About the author: Sandra Kramer-Kowalzik has worked with founder and leadership teams for more than 25 years, as founder and managing director of Koru Consulting GmbH. Her focus: fast-growing teams that want to make good decisions together.

Sources and further reading

Raichle, Marcus E. and Gusnard, Debra A. (2002). Appraising the brain’s energy budget. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 99(16), 10237-10238.

Peters, Achim; McEwen, Bruce S. and Friston, Karl (2017). Uncertainty and stress: Why it causes diseases and how it is mastered by the brain. Progress in Neurobiology, 156, 164-188.

Samuelson, William and Zeckhauser, Richard (1988). Status quo bias in decision making. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1(1), 7-59.

Dein nächster Schritt

Knirscht es bei euch gerade?

In einem kurzen Infogespräch schauen wir gemeinsam, wo bei euch Energie verloren geht und was ein guter nächster Schritt ist. Oder du schaust dir zuerst in Ruhe an, wie wir mit Gründer- und Führungsteams arbeiten.

WordPress Cookie Notice by Real Cookie Banner